9 Completeness and Compactifications
Recap: compactness in metric spaces
Definition 9.1.
is compact if every open cover of has a finite subcover. is limit point compact if every infinite subset of has a limit point. is sequentially compact if every sequence in has a convergent subsequence.
Theorem 9.2. For metric spaces, the 3 notions are equivalent.
We proved this except for a lemma (Lemma 2) which remained to prove:
Lemma 9.3 (Lebesgue numbers). If
(We’ve seen this hold for compact metric spaces, so it should hold!)
Proof. Suppose there exists an open cover
By sequential compactness, there exists a subsequence
Remark. This proof illustrates how arguments using sequential compactness are often more intuitive than those involving open covers: “if some property fails to hold uniformly, take a sequence of points where things get worse, extract a convergent subsequence, and see what goes wrong at the limit.”
Completeness
Theorem 9.4. Every compact metric space
Proof. Let
Corollary 9.5.
Proof. Every Cauchy sequence is bounded, hence contained in a compact subset, hence convergent. ∎
Corollary 9.6.
Proof. Given a Cauchy sequence
Now: given
Note. When
Compactification (Munkres §29)
Definition 9.7. A compactification of a (Hausdorff) topological space
Example 9.8.
This is not the only option: e.g.
The one-point compactification
The one-point compactification, if it exists, is unique.
Let
- a subset
is open in iff it is open in (subspace topology ); - a subset
containing is open in iff is closed, hence compact (we want compact), and a subset of (since ).
So we define:
Definition 9.9.
Theorem 9.10.
Proof.
Axioms of a topology: case by case for
’s and ’s. Arbitrary unions and finite intersections of a single type of open set are still of the same type (note: , and a finite union of compact subsets of is compact). Moreover, where is closed in , hence compact. ✓ is compact: if is an open cover of , then for some , and now the form an open cover of , so such that . Thus is a finite subcover.
∎
However, this
Definition 9.11.
Example 9.12.
Theorem 9.13. The one-point compactification
Proof.
Hausdorff we can separate points of by open subsets (in or in ). locally compact open sets and such that , i.e. we can separate points of from by open subsets in .
∎
Notes not reached in this lecture, covered at the start of Lecture 10
Countability axioms (§30)
Definition 9.14.
Example 9.15. Metric spaces are first-countable: at
In a first-countable space,
Definition 9.16.
Example 9.17.
Second-countable
Regular and normal spaces (§31–32)
Recall:
Stronger separation axioms:
Definition 9.18. Suppose one-point subsets
is regular if , closed disjoint from , disjoint open sets , . is normal if disjoint closed subsets, disjoint open sets , .
(The first implication: will see.)
Example 9.19.
Theorem 9.20.
- regular + second-countable
normal - Hausdorff + compact
normal
We won’t prove this, cf. Munkres §32. We did see, when proving that compact subsets of Hausdorff spaces are closed, that compact + Hausdorff
Theorem 9.21. Metric spaces are normal.
Proof. Let
We can now ask which topological spaces are metrizable. We’ve seen: metrizable
Theorem 9.22 (Urysohn metrization theorem). If
(The first condition is necessary; the second one is stronger than needed. The Nagata–Smirnov theorem gives a sharper criterion but is more technical to state and prove.)
Urysohn’s lemma
Urysohn’s lemma is the key ingredient in the proof of the metrization theorem.
Theorem 9.23 (Urysohn’s lemma). Let
Idea:
- Construct open sets
such that , and moreover . Also set for . - Define
, and show is continuous.
Step 1 uses the following reformulation of normality:
Lemma 9.24.
Proof.
Proof of Urysohn’s lemma
Proof. Step 1. Given
Next, we construct
Assuming
By induction, we construct in this way all the
We also set
Step 2. Define
Since
So it only remains to show that
: indeed, if then , so . : indeed, if then .
Now given an open interval
By the above observation,
Next we will prove the metrization theorem, namely that if